Black Onyx Meaning, Healing Properties & Spiritual Symbolism

Black onyx is a stone of strength and protection. Its deep black color absorbs light and negativity. In spiritual practice, this stone carries grounding and shielding energy.

The black onyx meaning often involves protection, willpower, and emotional strength. It is a stone of the root chakra, helping to dispel fear and build confidence. A spiritual meaning of black tourmaline shares that black-stone focus, though tourmaline carries a more electric energy.

Black onyx is used in crystal healing to ward off negativity, boost discipline, and support grounding. It can also symbolize resilience and inner strength. The stone's energy is protective and steady.

If you feel drawn to black onyx, it may signal a need for strength. A spiritual meaning of black obsidian also deals with black stones, though obsidian carries a more reflective energy.

Key Takeaways

  • Black onyx symbolizes protection, inner strength, resilience, and spiritual grounding.
  • Many traditions link it with the root chakra, the energy center governing stability and security.
  • People use black onyx during grief recovery, self-discipline work, meditation, and emotional protection.
  • The stone absorbs negative energy and is believed to create a protective energetic boundary.
  • Wearing black onyx consistently may support emotional control, mental clarity, and personal power.
Black Onyx Meaning, Healing Properties and Spiritual Symbolism

What Is Black Onyx?

Black onyx is a variety of chalcedony, a microcrystalline form of quartz. It forms in parallel bands, although the jet-black versions most commonly used in jewelry are often uniformly colored rather than visibly banded. Its surface polishes to a deep, glassy finish. That rich black appearance gives it a bold visual authority unlike most gemstones.

Mineralogically, onyx forms inside volcanic rocks and hydrothermal veins. Silica-rich solutions slowly deposit in layers within rock cavities. Over time, those layers compress into dense, smooth stone. The black coloring in onyx comes from iron oxide and carbon compounds that become embedded during formation.

Many people confuse black onyx with black tourmaline or obsidian. All three share dark surfaces and protective symbolism. However, each carries a distinct energy. Black tourmaline is associated with deflecting negativity. Obsidian reflects emotional truth sharply. Black onyx, by contrast, symbolizes endurance, inner discipline, and steady protection rather than aggressive deflection or raw emotional exposure.

Origins and Formation

Black onyx deposits exist across several continents. Brazil, India, Uruguay, Madagascar, and the United States are among the most significant sources. India has historically been one of the world’s largest suppliers of carved and polished black onyx pieces, many of which have appeared in jewelry, religious carvings, and decorative art for centuries.

The stone forms slowly through layered silica deposition. This gradual formation process mirrors black onyx’s spiritual symbolism. Many traditions associate the stone with patience, endurance, and strength built over time rather than power that arrives suddenly or easily.

Historically, artisans prized black onyx for its workability. It accepts carving and polishing exceptionally well. Ancient craftspeople used it for cameos, seals, rings, amulets, and decorative inlays. Its consistent texture and rich color made it one of the most widely used stones in ancient jewelry traditions spanning Egypt, Rome, Greece, and parts of Asia.

Key Properties

PropertyDetails
ColorJet black, sometimes banded with white
CompositionChalcedony (microcrystalline quartz)
Hardness6.5 to 7 on the Mohs scale
Chakra AssociationRoot chakra (also solar plexus)
SymbolismProtection, strength, grounding, resilience
Common SourcesBrazil, India, Uruguay, Madagascar, USA
TransparencyOpaque
Energy StyleGrounding, stabilizing, protective

Historical Use of Black Onyx

Ancient civilizations were drawn to black onyx centuries before modern crystal traditions took shape. Ancient Egyptians used it extensively in amulets, burial objects, and decorative jewelry. They believed the stone protected the dead during their journey into the afterlife. Egyptian artisans also carved onyx into small figures placed within tombs to offer spiritual guardianship.

Ancient Greeks and Romans associated onyx with strength and courage. Roman soldiers wore black onyx engraved with the image of Mars, the god of war, before entering battle. They believed the stone granted its wearer bravery, endurance, and protection from enemy forces. The name “onyx” itself comes from the Greek word meaning fingernail or claw, referencing a mythological story in which Cupid clipped the fingernails of the sleeping Venus. The clippings, which fell into the Ganges River, transformed into onyx stone.

In Arabic folklore, black onyx carried a less favorable reputation during certain historical periods. Some ancient Arabic texts referred to it as a stone that could increase sadness or conflict. This darker association highlights how cultural context significantly shapes a stone’s symbolic meaning across different traditions.

Ancient Persians and Chinese artisans also carved black onyx into amulets, seals, and ceremonial objects. Persian and Chinese traditions viewed it as a stone that absorbed negative energy and prevented harmful spiritual influences from reaching its wearer.

In later metaphysical and Western esoteric traditions, black onyx became firmly associated with personal power, self-mastery, emotional control, and spiritual protection. These themes have remained consistent through modern crystal healing practices.

5 Spiritual Meanings of Black Onyx

1. Protection and Energetic Boundaries

Black onyx is one of the most widely recognized protective stones in crystal traditions. Its spiritual reputation for protection spans continents and centuries. Ancient warriors, priests, and healers across multiple cultures turned to this stone during moments of vulnerability or danger. That protective symbolism has remained remarkably consistent through thousands of years of spiritual practice.

Spiritually, protection in the context of black onyx does not refer only to physical danger. Its energy is more often associated with emotional protection and energetic boundary-setting. Many people feel energetically drained after interacting with certain individuals or environments. Stress, conflict, emotional manipulation, harsh criticism, and emotional volatility from others can gradually deplete personal energy. Black onyx symbolically creates a boundary that limits how deeply those external forces penetrate a person’s emotional and energetic space.

Many practitioners describe this protective quality as feeling like a quiet shield rather than an aggressive barrier. Black onyx does not push back with force. Instead, it symbolizes steady containment. The stone energetically represents the idea that you do not have to absorb every emotional current that enters your environment.

This symbolism carries deep relevance in daily life. People in emotionally demanding professions such as healthcare, counseling, education, or social work often describe feeling energetically exhausted. Crystal healers frequently recommend black onyx for individuals in these fields because its symbolism centers on maintaining personal energy without emotional withdrawal. The stone represents boundaries that protect without creating coldness or detachment.

Black onyx also symbolizes spiritual protection from negative thought patterns. Fear, self-doubt, destructive thinking, and emotional instability can erode personal strength as effectively as any external pressure. Spiritually, the stone is believed to absorb and neutralize these internal negative energies. Its dense, dark surface visually reinforces this symbolism. Just as black absorbs all wavelengths of light, black onyx spiritually represents the absorption and containment of unwanted energy.

2. Inner Strength and Resilience

Black onyx has carried the symbolism of inner strength and resilience across virtually every culture that used it historically. Roman soldiers engraved it with images of strength. Egyptian priests placed it in protective amulets. Modern crystal practitioners continue connecting it with the capacity to endure difficulty, recover from hardship, and maintain personal power during challenging circumstances.

This association with strength does not refer to aggression or force. Black onyx represents a quieter, more enduring form of strength. It symbolizes the kind of resilience that keeps a person steady during grief, failure, prolonged uncertainty, or emotional exhaustion. Resilience in the context of black onyx means continuing forward even when progress feels invisible.

Many people seek this stone during periods of personal crisis. Grief, job loss, relationship breakdown, illness, trauma recovery, and financial hardship are common circumstances where individuals feel their inner strength significantly depleted. Spiritually, black onyx symbolizes emotional steadiness that does not require external conditions to improve before inner recovery can begin. It represents strength that comes from within rather than from favorable circumstances.

The stone’s geological formation reinforces this symbolism. Black onyx develops slowly under significant geological pressure. Its dense structure results from immense natural force applied consistently over enormous periods of time. Spiritually, this mirrors the way human resilience often grows through sustained pressure rather than comfortable ease. The same challenges that feel overwhelming in the moment frequently become the foundations of personal strength later.

Black onyx also symbolizes the capacity to hold emotional steadiness while pain is still present. Many people assume strength means the absence of pain or fear. Spiritually, black onyx challenges that assumption. Its symbolism reflects the understanding that strength often means remaining grounded and functional while simultaneously experiencing deep emotional difficulty. This distinction makes the stone particularly meaningful for people navigating loss, trauma, or prolonged personal hardship.

3. Grounding and Stability

Grounding is one of the most consistent themes associated with black onyx across healing traditions worldwide. The stone’s connection to the root chakra reflects this symbolism directly. Where some crystals elevate spiritual awareness toward higher energetic frequencies, black onyx works in the opposite direction. It pulls awareness downward into stability, physical presence, and emotional rootedness.

People often describe feeling ungrounded during periods of intense stress, grief, anxiety, or major life transition. Emotions become scattered. Decision-making feels difficult. Physical presence in daily life weakens as the mind races through worries, regrets, fears, and uncertainties. This state of energetic disconnection from practical reality is precisely where black onyx’s symbolism becomes most relevant.

Spiritually, grounding means returning your awareness to the present. It means feeling connected to your physical body, your immediate environment, and the practical circumstances of your life without being overwhelmed by abstract fears. Black onyx symbolically supports this return. Its dense, earthy energy encourages emotional anchoring during moments of psychological turbulence.

Many meditation practitioners use black onyx specifically for this purpose. Holding the stone during seated meditation helps some people feel more physically present and less mentally scattered. Its weight and smooth surface create a tactile anchor for attention. Spiritually, it symbolizes the process of bringing the mind back into the body during practices that might otherwise feel emotionally or energetically unmoored.

Grounding also carries practical implications beyond meditation. People who feel chronically disconnected from daily reality may struggle with productivity, emotional regulation, physical self-care, and consistent decision-making. Black onyx spiritually represents the stabilizing energy that makes consistent daily functioning possible. Its symbolism focuses less on inspiration or excitement and more on the steady foundation that allows purposeful action to occur.

4. Self-Discipline and Personal Mastery

Few stones carry the same association with self-discipline and personal mastery that black onyx does within crystal traditions. While many healing stones focus on emotional softening or openness, black onyx carries a more structured and internally rigorous spiritual identity. Its energy is frequently associated with mental focus, willpower, habit formation, and the capacity to delay emotional gratification.

Self-discipline in spiritual contexts involves more than behavioral control. It refers to the ability to regulate emotional reactions, maintain mental focus under pressure, and continue working toward meaningful goals when motivation naturally declines. Black onyx symbolizes the inner authority that makes this kind of sustained effort possible.

Many people struggle with self-discipline not from laziness but from emotional dysregulation. Fear, self-doubt, impulsivity, and emotional overwhelm regularly interrupt the pursuit of long-term goals. Spiritually, black onyx is believed to support the development of emotional steadiness that makes consistent behavior easier. It represents the internal quiet that allows a person to act from values and intention rather than from momentary emotional impulse.

The stone’s historical use by warriors directly reflects this symbolism. Warriors required mental discipline, emotional control, and psychological steadiness alongside physical capability. Wearing black onyx before battle was not merely about seeking protection from external harm. It also symbolized the internal battle for self-mastery, the discipline required to remain clear-headed and purposeful under extreme emotional and physical pressure.

Modern applications of this symbolism appear in areas such as career focus, personal development, recovery from addiction, athletic performance, and creative discipline. Black onyx spiritually represents the quiet determination that sustains effort over time, especially when progress feels slow, difficult, or uncertain.

5. Transformation Through Darkness

Black onyx carries a spiritual symbolism that many people overlook. It is a stone of transformation through darkness rather than transformation through light. This distinction is important. Many healing stones symbolize clarity, brightness, uplift, and positive emotional expansion. Black onyx walks a different spiritual path. It symbolizes the growth that happens during the darkest and most difficult chapters of human experience.

Grief, failure, loss, trauma, and emotional crisis are rarely pleasant. Yet within many spiritual traditions, these experiences also carry the seeds of profound personal transformation. Darkness in the symbolic sense does not mean something negative. It means the fertile, quiet space where internal change develops before it becomes visible externally.

Black onyx spiritually represents the capacity to remain present and spiritually engaged during difficult periods rather than fleeing from them. It symbolizes the willingness to sit with pain, uncertainty, and emotional difficulty without numbing out, collapsing inward, or abandoning the growth that those experiences eventually make possible.

This symbolism connects deeply with many philosophical and spiritual traditions. In Jungian psychology, the concept of the shadow refers to the unconscious aspects of the personality that individuals prefer to deny or avoid. Genuine psychological growth requires honest engagement with those shadow aspects rather than continued suppression. Black onyx spiritually mirrors this principle. Its dark surface represents the willingness to look inward honestly rather than remaining comfortable on the surface.

Many people find black onyx especially meaningful during significant life transitions where old identities, relationships, or life structures must be released before new ones can emerge. Career endings, relationship losses, spiritual crises, and personal reinvention often involve extended periods of uncertainty and internal darkness before clarity or direction becomes visible. Black onyx symbolizes trusting that process and remaining grounded within it rather than forcing premature resolution.

6 Healing Properties of Black Onyx

1. Emotional Stability

Black onyx is widely associated with emotional stability because its energy centers on emotional steadiness rather than emotional amplification. Where some crystals heighten emotional sensitivity or encourage emotional release, black onyx tends to stabilize emotional responses. Many people describe its influence as emotionally anchoring, particularly during periods of heightened emotional volatility.

Emotional instability often appears during grief, stress, relationship conflict, major transitions, or prolonged periods of uncertainty. Reactions become disproportionate. Emotional overwhelm arrives more frequently. Small triggers create large emotional responses because the underlying emotional foundation has been weakened by sustained pressure. Black onyx spiritually represents the process of rebuilding that emotional foundation layer by layer.

Many practitioners believe the stone helps people slow their emotional reactions. Rather than responding immediately from a place of fear, anger, or anxiety, individuals who work with black onyx symbolism often describe developing a brief internal pause before emotional responses surface. That pause creates space for more measured, intentional responses rather than reactive ones.

Emotional stability also supports physical health. Chronic emotional dysregulation contributes to elevated stress hormones, disrupted sleep, immune suppression, and cardiovascular strain. While black onyx is not a medical treatment, its symbolic role in emotional stabilization connects it to broader well-being. Calmer emotional responses create calmer physical states, which gradually support healthier daily functioning.

2. Mental Focus and Clarity

Mental clarity is one of the most valued healing properties attributed to black onyx. Many crystal practitioners and spiritual enthusiasts use the stone specifically during periods when mental focus feels fragmented, decision-making feels overwhelming, or mental clarity has been clouded by emotional distress, stress, or exhaustion.

Mental fog often accompanies grief, anxiety, burnout, and major life transitions. The mind races between possibilities, fears, regrets, and responsibilities without landing clearly on any single point of focus. This mental scattering makes it difficult to think through complex situations, make confident decisions, or maintain consistent attention on meaningful work. Black onyx spiritually represents the grounding of scattered mental energy into focused awareness.

Its association with the root chakra reinforces this property. When the root chakra is energetically balanced, many practitioners describe experiencing a clearer sense of mental presence, reduced anxiety, and greater capacity for practical decision-making. Black onyx’s grounding symbolism supports this energetic foundation, making mental clarity more accessible during periods of internal turbulence.

Many students, writers, professionals, and creative individuals keep black onyx in their workspaces for this reason. The stone’s presence serves as both a tactile grounding tool and a symbolic reminder to narrow attention from general overwhelm toward specific, purposeful focus.

3. Grief and Loss Recovery

Black onyx holds a uniquely significant place in grief recovery traditions. Ancient Egyptians placed it in burial chambers. Many cultures have historically associated the stone with death, transition, and the spiritual journey of the soul. Rather than avoiding these associations, black onyx’s relationship with grief makes it particularly meaningful during bereavement.

Grief is one of the most emotionally destabilizing human experiences. The loss of a person, relationship, identity, or life chapter disrupts emotional functioning on a deep level. Feelings of emptiness, confusion, emotional numbness, anger, profound sadness, and disorientation are all common grief responses. Many people feel profoundly ungrounded during bereavement. Daily routines lose their structure. The future feels uncertain and frightening.

Black onyx spiritually symbolizes steady presence during the experience of loss. It does not rush grief toward resolution. It does not deny the reality of pain. Instead, it represents the grounded, stable energy that helps a person remain functional and emotionally present while moving through grief at its own natural pace.

Many grief counselors who incorporate crystal healing into their practices describe black onyx as emotionally supportive during the early and middle stages of grief, when emotional intensity peaks and grounding feels most necessary. Its symbolism encourages people to honor grief rather than suppress it while maintaining enough inner stability to continue functioning in daily life.

4. Protection From Negative Energy

Black onyx is perhaps most commonly known for its protective energetic properties. Within crystal healing traditions, the stone is frequently described as absorbing and neutralizing negative energy before it can significantly affect the wearer’s emotional or energetic state.

Negative energy in this context refers broadly to emotional toxicity, energetic depletion, psychic stress, and harmful thought patterns rather than supernatural forces. Environments that carry high emotional tension, relationships characterized by manipulation or emotional volatility, and workplaces filled with persistent conflict all create energetic conditions that gradually drain personal resilience.

Black onyx symbolically acts as a buffer in these environments. Many practitioners describe wearing or carrying the stone as creating an invisible but felt boundary between their personal energy and the disruptive energy present in challenging environments. This does not mean emotional detachment or avoidance of responsibility. Instead, it represents remaining emotionally present without becoming emotionally consumed.

The stone’s dark color reinforces this symbolism at a visual and intuitive level. Black absorbs rather than reflects light. In the same symbolic way, black onyx is believed to absorb negative energetic input before it reaches deeper emotional layers. Many people who work in high-stress or emotionally demanding environments report that wearing black onyx helps them feel less depleted at the end of demanding days.

5. Building Confidence and Personal Power

Confidence and personal power are healing properties regularly attributed to black onyx, particularly within traditions focused on self-development and emotional empowerment. Low confidence often follows extended periods of failure, criticism, emotional trauma, or prolonged self-doubt. The internal narrative shifts from capability toward inadequacy, and that shift quietly undermines motivation, decision-making, and emotional risk-taking.

Black onyx spiritually represents the recovery of personal power from within rather than its restoration through external validation. Its energy focuses on internal authority rather than social approval. Many crystal practitioners describe the stone as helping individuals reconnect with their own sense of capability and self-trust during periods when external circumstances have weakened that inner foundation.

This symbolism is particularly meaningful for individuals recovering from emotionally abusive relationships, workplace harassment, public failure, or prolonged periods of feeling invisible or undervalued. Black onyx’s protective symbolism combines with its strength symbolism to represent the reclamation of emotional autonomy and personal dignity that difficult experiences may have temporarily diminished.

6. Overcoming Fear and Anxiety

Fear and anxiety are among the most common emotional challenges people bring to crystal healing practices. Black onyx carries a specific association with overcoming fear because its historical use in battle directly involved helping warriors face situations that naturally generated profound fear.

Modern fears rarely involve physical battlefields. However, the psychological experience of confronting fear shares significant structural similarities regardless of the source. Job interviews, public speaking, difficult conversations, medical procedures, major decisions, and social vulnerability all activate fear responses that can feel disproportionately overwhelming in the moment.

Black onyx spiritually symbolizes the inner courage to move forward despite fear rather than the absence of fear itself. This distinction matters deeply. Courage does not mean feeling no fear. It means remaining grounded, purposeful, and functionally effective even when fear is actively present. Black onyx represents that specific quality of grounded courage.

Many individuals who struggle with chronic anxiety find the stone’s grounding symbolism particularly relevant. Anxiety frequently involves the mind generating catastrophic future scenarios while the body remains anchored in the present. Black onyx’s strong association with present-moment grounding symbolically counters the anxious mind’s tendency to project into worst-case future possibilities.

Black Onyx and Chakra Connection

Black onyx is most strongly associated with the root chakra, known in Sanskrit as Muladhara. The root chakra sits at the base of the spine and governs fundamental human experiences including safety, security, physical grounding, survival instincts, and the basic sense of belonging in the world.

When the root chakra functions energetically well, people often describe feeling emotionally steady, physically grounded, financially confident, and fundamentally safe. When it feels energetically blocked or depleted, the opposite pattern often emerges. Anxiety, financial fear, physical disconnection, emotional insecurity, and a chronic sense of instability may develop.

Black onyx’s deep connection to earth energy, stability, and physical groundedness makes it one of the most frequently recommended stones for root chakra healing work. Its dense weight, dark color, and earthy energy reinforce its alignment with the root chakra’s foundational themes.

Some practitioners also associate black onyx with the solar plexus chakra, the energy center connected with personal power, self-confidence, willpower, and individual identity. The stone’s symbolism of inner strength and self-mastery creates a natural bridge between these two energy centers. Many healers believe working with black onyx simultaneously strengthens both the physical grounding of the root chakra and the personal authority of the solar plexus.

How to Wear Black Onyx Jewelry for Spiritual Growth

People wear black onyx jewelry in various ways depending on their spiritual intentions. Because the stone connects strongly with protection and grounding, many practitioners prefer wearing it in forms that maintain consistent skin contact throughout the day.

Black onyx bracelets are among the most popular choices. Worn on the left wrist within many crystal traditions, they symbolize receiving protective and grounding energy inward. Worn on the right wrist, they symbolize projecting that energy outward toward your environment. Some people choose based on personal intuition rather than formal tradition.

Black onyx rings carry symbolism related to personal power and decision-making. Wearing the stone on the hands keeps its protective and empowering energy present during interpersonal interactions, work responsibilities, and daily tasks that require focused attention and personal authority.

Black onyx pendants worn at the throat or chest connect the stone’s energy with communication and emotional expression. Some practitioners believe this placement strengthens the ability to speak with clarity and personal authority, particularly during difficult or high-stakes conversations.

Many people combine black onyx with complementary stones. Clear quartz amplifies energetic clarity. Hematite strengthens grounding and protection. Red jasper supports physical vitality alongside black onyx’s stabilizing energy. Labradorite balances black onyx’s strong protective energy with intuitive awareness and spiritual insight.

Spiritual use varies significantly between individuals. Some people feel an immediate and powerful connection with black onyx. Others appreciate its aesthetic qualities without attributing metaphysical meaning. Both approaches are entirely valid.

Caring for Black Onyx Jewelry

Black onyx is relatively durable at 6.5 to 7 on the Mohs hardness scale, making it more resistant to scratching than softer stones such as opal or moonstone. However, it still requires thoughtful care to maintain its deep polish and structural integrity over time.

Store black onyx separately from harder gemstones such as diamonds or sapphires to prevent surface scratching. A soft fabric pouch or padded jewelry box protects its polished surface during storage.

Clean black onyx gently using lukewarm water, mild soap, and a soft cloth. Avoid ultrasonic cleaners, steam cleaning machines, and harsh chemical solutions. These methods may damage the surface finish or weaken the stone’s structural stability over time.

Remove black onyx jewelry before swimming, heavy physical activity, or household cleaning with chemical products. Chlorine and harsh cleaning agents can dull the stone’s surface polish with repeated exposure.

Avoid prolonged exposure to direct sunlight. While black onyx is not as photosensitive as some lighter stones, extended UV exposure may gradually affect surface appearance over many years.

Many spiritual practitioners also energetically cleanse black onyx regularly because the stone is believed to absorb negative energy. Common cleansing methods include overnight placement in moonlight, brief burial in dry earth or salt, sound cleansing with bowls or bells, and smudging with cleansing herbs such as sage or cedar. These practices vary according to personal spiritual traditions and preferences.

Table: Black Onyx Meaning at a Glance

AspectDetails
Primary MeaningProtection, inner strength, grounding
Chakra AssociationRoot chakra (also solar plexus)
Main Spiritual SymbolismResilience, personal power, transformation
Common ColorsJet black, occasionally banded with white
Hardness6.5 to 7 Mohs
Main SourcesBrazil, India, Uruguay, Madagascar, USA
Emotional AssociationsCourage, stability, self-discipline, confidence
Popular Jewelry TypesBracelets, rings, pendants, beads
Spiritual UsesProtection, grounding, grief recovery, focus
Care NeedsGentle cleaning, separate storage, avoid chemicals

A Final Note

Black onyx stands apart from many healing stones because its symbolism carries weight rather than lightness. It does not promise warmth, comfort, or gentle emotional softening. Instead, it offers something many people need even more. Steadiness. Strength. Protection. And the quiet certainty that you can move through difficulty without losing yourself.

Its spiritual meaning centers on protection, resilience, grounding, self-mastery, and transformation through the darker chapters of human experience. Whether viewed through a spiritual lens or appreciated simply for its striking beauty, black onyx continues to resonate with people who are navigating difficulty, rebuilding personal strength, or seeking a deeper sense of inner stability.

If black onyx has caught your attention, that pull may carry personal meaning worth exploring. Some people wear it for energetic protection. Others keep it nearby as a daily reminder of their own resilience. Many simply appreciate the calm authority that its dark, polished surface seems to radiate.

Whatever draws you toward it, black onyx has spent thousands of years quietly earning its reputation as one of the most powerful and meaningful stones in human spiritual history.

Leave a Comment